Real learning is the ability to adopt what you know and know-how to do and adapt it under an everchanging variety of circumstances.
No point beating around the pedagogical bush. I’ve been asked by a number of readers “How would you define real learning?”. Real learning is the ability to adopt what you know and know-how to do and adapt it under an everchanging variety of circumstances. Learning is an ongoing process. That’s my definition and I’m sticking to it.
Learning in a classroom involves the use of short-term memory. It is all about remembering – regurgitating – then forgetting. Rote learning. You remember the lesson, and show that you remember through a variety of tests and then move on. Moving on is all about forgetting. With two interesting and notable exceptions. Art. Science. The reason is simple. Art and Science require an evolving degree of knowledge from basic to advanced. Think learning to play the tuba or building a car. It’s the kind of subject matter that was always learned by apprenticing or being tutored by a master. You need basic math to get to algebraic equations and then onto experimental astrophysics. If you don’t master the fingering you cannot play a decent scale let alone get to a Bach sonata.
Real learning is somewhat like sleeping. You do not go to sleep you go through a process of sleeping, through stages. If you’re constantly interrupted you wake up the next morning feeling like you had a bad nights sleep. Real learning requires stages as well and you cannot skip over any of them. Even though I do not play the game, I use golf as an example to explain the process of real learning. Interesting that a recent number of neuroscience researchers have been doing the same. They talk about reaching a point during the adoption phase where you peak at the physical learning part of the game, and you move on to the strategic or mental part. Your body has practiced so much it has really learned what to do, and now it’s on to the rest of you to learn to find the spot where you want the ball to go. Feel the wind. Sense the way the green curves. Before you get to that stage you spend a lot of time looking all over the place. They followed the eye patterns of novice golfers on a green, lining up a putt, and when they illustrated their eye movements it looked like someone had thrown a plate of spaghetti on the green. Lines and loops going every which way. With the top golfers, the eye patterns were a few lines most of them moving directly towards the cup.
When you have learned to play well enough, the body part of the learning to play golf is done, and your mind is free to focus focus focus. You reached the point where you are in the zone. It’s like sleep where you managed to avoid being interrupted until you reach Phase 5 – real dreaming.
It’s an incredible waste of time. So much of what we learn in school is forgotten. It does not build on itself from experience. Not just experience in the sense of doing but even experience of knowing more. Even though history, for example, should take you from the Year One up until Today, and then deeper into every era, most of what you learn about history you quickly test and rapidly excrete. That’s just the way the system measures and rewards the student. It has nothing to do with really learning about history. Or any other subject as well.
Side note: An alternative example of real learning. I had the advantage of going to a school – at the time it was called “experimental” – where we spent two years moving through time. Going to school was like being in a time machine. For example, when we were learning about the period called the 16th century, we did not have just one short history lesson, but learned everything 16th century. We were taught about their maps, arts, crafts, clothes, sciences, cultures, politics, music, poetry, literature, plays, travels, trade, religion, wars, weapons, you name it. We were immersed in the 16th century. It felt like we were in the 16th century. It’s just another model that while not perfect, teaches you more about history than the 3 weeks you get in most schools before jumping ahead to the 17th.
Back to real learning versus rote learning. There are two very surprising elements to real learning that the fake pale imitation excludes. Disables. Prohibits.
The first is that real learning starts with forgetting – making room for the new. If you have a hard time forgetting the old you will have a difficult time starting to learn the new. If you have had a hard time learning what you know then you will also try and hold on to the old and not learn the new. And be honest we’ve all experienced it. That moment when they upgrade or change a process or procedure or tool you know how to use and you exclaim “Hey, I just learned how to use it, and they’re already changing it!” So you need to be able to clear the mental cache in a materialistic sense of the brain.
The second big part – really big part – of real learning is failure. Failure happens since when you are adapting what you adopted as learning from the last time you did it or thought it or spoke it or argued it or whatever you will experience failure. Smart people who are real learners go “Oh I failed, okay what did I do wrong and how can I fix it so next time I do it right?” Einstein. Edison. Dyson. So you need to accept and enable failure for the process of real learning to work. And if “failure is not an option” then you will fail and not learn anything.
If you are involved in any kind of learning, and forgetting and failure are not emphasized as part of the learning … leave. You will not really learn a thing. If forgetting what you know at the start (I love those movie scene where the Sargent – Captain – Leader says “Okay you idiots for starters I want you to forget everything you ever learned!”) then real learning will not happen. By the way forgetting is a brain function as studied by neuroscience as remembering. Imagine what your life would be like if you could not forget what you learned the first (and last) time you learned it …
Now there is what I call “High Wire Training” where failure leads to your or someone else’s death. Walking across the Grand Canyon. Going into battle in Afghanistan. Responding to a 911 emergency involving a gang shooting or horrible car accident. Let’s be honest. Most of what we learn is not in the High Wire Training category. If it was, this would be a very different blog … hmmm … next time.
To sum it up. Learning is a natural brain process that occurs in stages. Real learning enables all the stages. Rote learning disables the stages and focuses on a small part of the process. I’m not sure what value rote learning has in today’s world. Then again I’m not sure it ever had any real value. What’s the point of spending time and energy learning something only to forget it almost immediately after the test? Makes me think of the following opening of this clip: